The third and final season of Star Trek: Picard has now unspooled in full on Paramount Plus, and its soundtrack is also now readily available. The third season was heavily promoted, promising a full reunion of the crew of Star Trek: The Next Generation, and late in the season, even miraculously brought back the Next Generation’s beloved Enterprise from what we’d all assumed was its final resting place on the planet onto whose surface it crashed in 1994’s Star Trek: Generations. Of course, to bring all of the characters back to their original places on that iconic bridge, there had to be a tremendous threat that they’d risk everything to fight, and perhaps predictably, that turned out to be the Borg, a well-worn Star Trek foe getting its third wildly different treatment in as many consecutive seasons of Picard. Whether it all holds together as a story without relying on dropping nostalgia bombs on the audience to distract them from the predictability of the plot – look, space squirrel! – is something I suspect fans and critics will be debating for years to come. In the meantime, the actors got to work together one more time, save the universe one more time, and pay their mortgages.
Into this fray walked two composers new to the franchise. Where Jeff Russo – also the resident composer of Star Trek: Discovery – had performed similar duties for Picard’s first and second seasons, giving those proceedings a somewhat more contemplative feel with the obligatory ramping-up-to-maximum-orchestral-anxiety required by end-of-act and end-of-episode breaks, Picard’s showrunners opted to bring in some fresh talent for the show’s last season. It’s also possible that they were looking to bring in talent that wouldn’t balk at the producers’ requests to reference Jerry Goldsmith and other previous Star Trek composers often. (There’s less money to be made from a new arrangement of someone else’s composition than there is from composing something completely original, but make no mistake, with all of the other easter eggs in the show, the producers of Picard make it clear they wanted to hear Goldsmith themes and hear them often.) What a spot to be in: your name is appearing in a high-profile streaming show with the weight of the expectations of the entire franchise on your shoulders, but what you’ve been asked to do is play Jerry Goldsmith’s greatest hits, with some stylistic nods to James Horner’s nautical stylings from Star Trek II. What a musical Kobayashi Maru scenario. (And one that’s likely to keep repeating itself as various long-running IPs play the nostalgia card more blatantly.)
The good news is that the two composers get quite a few original licks in during their sprints between the Goldsmith-ian goalposts. Barton, who did the music for the game Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order and previously worked with Picard showrunner Terry Matalas on Syfy’s series adaptation of 12 Monkeys (of which Matalas was also the showrunner), and Wiedmann, whose credits include numerous DC Comics direct-to-video animation projects, are no strangers to the epic side of the genre, and they bring that sound in bucketfuls. Rapid-fire brass runs, sinister bass notes, and the requisite strings are all there in abundance, along with a very few fleeting hints of the legendary Blaster Beam, but when it’s time for Picard and company to save the day, the Goldsmith theme from Star Trek: The Motion Picture (adapted to serve as the theme for The Next Generation’s TV run) returns, along with hints of Goldsmith’s Star Trek: First Contact Theme. Ironically, it’s everything that the weekly episode scores for Next Generation were strictly forbidden to be by that show’s showrunner: loud, thematic, percussive, and developing Goldsmith’s theme(s) as a motif. Courage’s Star Trek theme is quoted occasionally as well, and especially in the suite of material from the first episode, there are audible references to the style, if not necessarily the melodies, of James Horner’s Star Trek II score. In tracks like “Blood In The Water” there are even hints of Don Davis’ action music stylings from The Matrix trilogy.
Some of the best-utilized quotes are the most understated: the track “Legacies”, accompanying the lovingly languid survey of the ships in Geordi’s Fleet Museum, quotes Dennis McCarthy’s Deep Space Nine theme, Courage’s original series theme, Goldsmith’s Star Trek: Voyager theme, and Leonard Rosenman’s theme from Star Trek IV (as that movie’s recovered Klingon ship is glimpsed), all in the space of three minutes with a lovely subtlety (which is good, because the scene it accompanied was not a thing of subtely, bringing the story to a standstill to wallow in its nostalgia grace notes). The Rosenman theme – and indeed, that movie’s entire underrated score – is often omitted from the Star Trek musical canon, and it’s nice to hear it reclaim its place. Maximum Goldsmithification resumes with the track “Make It So”, unveiling the restored Enterprise-D.
It’s all nicely put together, but it reminds me of when, in the 1990s, with my ridiculously massive 18-disc Pioneer magazine CD changer loaded down with every available Star Trek TV and film soundtrack, I would hit “shuffle” and just bask in it. What I liked about Russo’s approach was that it was very much in line with Star Trek: Picard’s original remit to move the character, and his universe, forward into a new context, filled with new and sometimes less-than-sympathetic characters we hadn’t met before. It was something new. Both this season of the show, and its soundtrack, try very hard to hit shuffle play on Star Trek’s greatest hits, and so a lot of it sounds like something you’ve heard before, which does a disservice to the decent original material that Barton and Wiedmann did manage to squeeze in between the musical references. The point of Picard, the series, in its original formulation, was to use one character as a jumping-off point into new territory for the franchise. This season seemed like a decisive step away from that goal. I wonder what we might have gotten if the two talented composers hired for this gig were told to avoid all the Jerry Goldsmith references and chart their own course.
- Beverly Crusher (3:02)
- Old Communicator (1:58)
- Hello, Beautiful (1:57)
- Leaving Spacedock (3:44)
- I Like That Seven! (3:29)
- Breaking the Beam (3:59)
- The Shrike (3:34)
- Picard’s Answer (4:08)
- Riker and Jack (2:08)
- Call Me Number One (2:02)
- No Win Scenario (3:57)
- Blood in the Water (2:58)
- Let’s Go Home (3:24)
- Flying Blind (5:51)
- A New Family (4:16)
- Klingons Never Disappoint (5:32)
- I Do See You (5:26)
- Legacies (3:15)
- Evolution (2:44)
- La Forges (2:08)
- Invisible Rescue (3:34)
- Catch Me First (2:32)
- Proteus (3:46)
- Dominion (7:04)
- Lower The Partition (3:38)
- Get Off My Bridge (4:26)
- Family Reunion (3:18)
- Impossible (1:37)
- Frontier Day (2:43)
- Hail The Fleet (4:03)
- You Have The Conn (3:44)
- Make It So (6:02)
- This Ends Tonight (3:07)
- Battle on the Bridge (2:58)
- All That’s Left (2:02)
- Annihilate (3:05)
- Trust Me (2:06)
- The Last Generation (2:51)
- Where It All Began (2:19)
- The Missing Part Of Me (4:30)
- Must Come To An End (1:32)
- A New Day (3:22)
- Legacy and Future (1:44)
- Names Mean Everything (1:43)
- The Stars – End Credits (2:59)
Released by: Lakeshore Records
Release date: April 20, 2023
Total running time: 2:30:15
…
Read more
Things take a more sensitive turn halfway through “A Good Legend” with the scene that either launched a thousand gleeful fanfics or launched a thousand middle-aged male fan tantrums, as the Doctor and Yaz skip some rocks across the water and discuss whether there’s any “there” there. It’s a nicely understated closer for the show, though I’m still undecided on whether the Doctor somehow being aware of an impending regeneration (something that started with Tom Baker’s exit) becoming a recurring trope of the show (used in the last run of specials for both David Tennant and Jodie Whittaker). Either way, the music for the scene is easily the standout highlight of this soundtrack.
