Categories
DVD TV Series Video

Blake’s 7: The Complete Series Four

5 min read

Order it in theLogBook.com StoreA season whose production was revealed to the cast and crew at the same time as the general public – i.e. during the end credits of the last episode of the third season – this final baker’s dozen of Blake’s 7 episodes marks a radical shift in the series’ direction, at least on par with Babylon 5’s crew abandoning their Earthforce allegiance to join the “army of light.” The finale of the previous season had dispensed with Blake, the all-powerful starship Liberator (and its ever-helpful computer, Zen), and any hope of the surviving Liberator crew escaping the hellish artificial planet appropriately named Terminal. The bad guys had won, it seemed – but surely that couldn’t stand as the end of the series, though the BBC’s battle for ratings had more to do with the final season’s existence than the battle between good and evil.

Blake's 7: The Complete Series Four Blake's 7: The Complete Series Four

All 13 episodes are included here, including the shockingly doom-laden series finale, Blake, which proceeded to make the third season’s finale look like light comedy. As shock endings go, Blake’s 7 still ranks as one of the all time greats. Does it leave things open-ended for a continuation? Depends on how you interpret it. Does it give the show closure? Yes, and violently so.

Blake, as it so happens, is one of only two episodes with a commentary for this season, the other being Assassin. Paul “Avon” Darrow and Jacqueline “Servalan” Pearce ham it up during Assassin, gleefully reminiscing about the show and even riffing mercilessly on one of the guest stars’ performance (!!). Blake's 7: The Complete Series FourDarrow joins writer/script editor Chris Boucher and Blake himself, Gareth Thomas, for the final episode, which becomes rather amusing when one realizes that Thomas hasn’t seen the show in ages and has forgotten what happens in it!

There are also, at last, some other substantial extras in this set, directed by Kevin Davies. Davies had originally devised an affectionate four-part “making of” special for the Blake’s 7 DVDs, only to run afoul of B7E, the outfit that bought the Blake’s 7 rights from the estate of the show’s late creator, Terry Nation. Davies’ original documentary would have affectionately addressed the many charges over the years that Blake’s 7 had become more than a little campy, which reportedly was an aspect that B7E wished to bury as they tried to launch a gritty, modern-day revival of the series (in any case, that attempt has been stalled indefinitely since the departure of Paul Darrow from the B7E project). As the new rights holders, however, B7E had – and used – the power to veto Davies’ documentary in its entirety, which held up the release of the first season DVDs for a year.

Blake's 7: The Complete Series Four Blake's 7: The Complete Series Four

In any case, some of the material gathered by Davies finally sees the light of day here in a handful of new documentary pieces which apparently did pass muster with B7E; “Special Sounds: Radiophonics” focuses on the creation of Blake’s 7’s unique sound effects by, initially, Richard Yeoman-Clark and eventually Liz Parker of the BBC Radiophonic Workshop. Workshop archivist Mark Ayres also appears to discuss the preservation of the material in question. Actually, having recently seen a similar documentary about the Workshop’s 1960s era in the Doctor Who: The Beginning box set, it has to be said that this is a nice companion piece. “Ken Ledsham’s Blake’s 7 Designs” focuses on the enormous problems encountered by the set designer who took over early in the series – only to find that his budget had already been blown on the elaborate Liberator standing sets. And “Forever Avon” accompanies Paul Darrow on a vist to a space exhibit at the London Science Museum to discuss the legacy of his most famous role. The Davies documentaries are, as always, great fun, though I did find some of the editing in the first half of “Forever Avon” to be ponderously slow in places.

Blake's 7: The Complete Series Four Blake's 7: The Complete Series Four

Other period Blake’s 7-related clips are included from the usual suspects – Pebble Mill At One and Blue Peter – along with the very amusing fourth season edition of “Blake’s Bloops,” replete with gun prop miscues, stumbles, and Jackie Pearce and guest star Betty Marsden infamously fluffing a scene from Assassin repeatedly. More bloopers and misfires can be found in a section of exceedingly rare raw studio recording tape, including the infamous Gold blooper in which Darrow, as Avon, is meant to fail to reach an airlock door in time, but due to a problem with the door prop, he instead quite casually walks into the airlock in question and laughs “Well, that’d solve a lot of problems then, wouldn’t it?” The studio session tape is accompanied by an informative series of subtitles, which reveal that the raw tape had been recorded over with a live political event – except for the last half hour of the tape, which revealed these gems.

Compared to previous seasons of Blake’s 7 on DVD, there’s a wealth of material here, and while everything covered there is fascinating, it really just amounts to a bittersweet reminder that a more extensive documentary covering the series as a whole exists somewhere. Still, it makes for a nice DVD package, and hopefully, somewhere down the road, that documentary can still be released, even if it winds up being of the “uncensored! unauthorized!” variety.… Read more

Categories
DVD TV Series Video

Buck Rogers In The 25th Century: The Complete Epic Series

8 min read

Order it in theLogBook.com StoreFresh from having Battlestar Galactica wrested from his grip by ABC, producer Glen Larson high-tailed it to another SF dream project of his, NBC’s revival of the comic strip/old-time-radio classic Buck Rogers In The 25th Century. Based on Robert C. Dille’s seminal 1930s space hero, this updated version of the legend was being retooled for a 20th century audience – a little more enlightened, one might think, but only a little.

The first season of Buck Rogers opens with the two-hour debut movie, setting the stage for the show and populating it with heroes and villains. In some ways, the tone of the premiere is different, but in other ways it sets the template for the entire first year: Gil Gerard is clearly The Hero, but sometimes that means he’s The Hero on a Shatneriffic scale – he’s in almost every scene, and a healthy share of the scenes he’s not in involve his friends back on Earth worrying about him. Still, Gerard’s performance is worthy of praise here – he can milk the wink-and-a-nudge punch line, but he does find some of the gravity of Buck’s situation, being stranded out of time with no hope of returning to the time and the people he remembers. (If this show were done today, there’s a very good chance that this gravity would be played as overwrought pathos, so it’s actually a nice balance.)

Buck Rogers In The 25th Century: The Complete Epic Series Buck Rogers In The 25th Century: The Complete Epic Series

The supporting cast is solid and talented across the board, though their characters aren’t always as good as their performances. There are many instances where Erin Gray gives Colonel Wilma Deering the kind of steely determination that one would expect of someone who holds such a high rank in the Earth Defense Directorate, but just as often she’s reduced to doe-eyed half-whispers of “Oh Buck!” – partly a product of the charcter’s 1930s origins, but also partly a product of the show’s 1970s pedigree. She seems to be at the mercy of the script and whoever happens to be the director of that week’s episode. With small actor Felix Silla in the suit and cartoon voice veteran Mel Blanc providing the voice, Twiki, of course, steals the show at every opportunity, and shamelessly so. I had forgotten how steady, unflappable and yet funny Tim O’Connor was as Dr. Elias Huer; sadly the writers couldn’t decide between Huer as level-headed genius and Huer as impossibly clueless comic straight-man.

The first season is quite a mix storywise; some of its stories are hackneyed holdovers from 1950s sci-fi B flicks, some are episodes of the Love Boat transposed into space, and a few are interesting. With writers like Alan Brennert (Twilight Zone, Star Trek: Enterprise) and Jaron Summers (Star Trek) on board, you might kid yourself momentarily about finding some serious SF, but don’t fool yourself too much – Buck Rogers’ millieu isn’t hard science fiction, but spandex, lip gloss, and as much special effects spectacle and big-name guest star power as the show could squeeze out of its budget. The guest star aspect of the show can’t be played down – getting Jerry Orbach, Michael Ansara, Richard Moll, Frank Gorshin, Jack Palance, Ray Walston, Peter Graves, Jamie Lee Curtis, Cesar Romero, Roddy McDowell, Buster Crabbe (the original silver screen Buck Rogers himself!) and even a decent guest turn out of Gary Coleman, all in one season, was, if not one coup, then a whole series of them. (But just as often, the guest casting coups were undermined by putting these legends from the silver age of Hollywood on the screen next to models-turned-actresses who, despite being easy on the eyes, could barely act.) This may well be the cause of the many reports that Gil Gerard and the show’s producers and writing staff threw more sparks than a malfunctioning spaceship control console in clashes over story content and the direction of the series as a whole.

This, of course, led to yet another show being yanked out of Glen Larson’s hands, and the very noticeable change of tone between seasons. Incoming producer John Mantley had been the showrunner for much of Gunsmoke’s time on the air, and he was given a half-season order and instructions to redirect the show in a much more Star Trek-influenced, action-adventure-with-a-brain direction. Gone were Dr. Huer, Dr. Theopolis, Princess Ardala, Killer Kane, and indeed the entire Earth-under-siege element of the show, and the characters who were retained – basically Buck, Wilma and Twiki – were now assigned to the starship Searcher, seeking out lost human colonies, new life, new civilizations and, on a whole, a little less lip gloss. Universal and NBC made it known very forcefully that this would be a whole new show: Mantley proposed a transitional episode to see off the departing characters and introduce the Searcher/colony plotline, and was turned down.

The most visible change in season two, however, was the addition of Thom Christopher as Hawk. Even more unflappable than Dr. Huer (no pun intended), Hawk was a further indication of the Star Trek influence, commenting on human foibles and strengths and always remaining the outsider. The character was key to the two-hour relaunch of the series, which also saw the addition of Wilfred Hyde-White as the doddering science Dr. Goodfellow, Jay Garner as Admiral Asimov, and a new robot named Crichton to serve both as a useful tool for dropping exposition into the story and as the straight-man for Twiki’s one-liners. Also worth noting in the second season episodes is a new musical direction courtesy of Bruce Broughton, who has since moved on to much bigger and better projects.

Buck Rogers In The 25th Century: The Complete Epic Series Buck Rogers In The 25th Century: The Complete Epic Series

The second season episodes suffer from a strange dichotomy – they’re trying to be smarter, but they’re also trying to maintain the lightheartedness of the first season…and they never quite achieved either extreme successfully. As politically incorrect as the first season may seem now, with its scantily-clad women and wink-wink-nudge-nudge humor, it’s just more fun than season two. Even halfway through what episodes were produced for the second season, one can see a gradual reversal of some of the changes – one episode focuses on a group of telekinetic dwarves’ overtly sexual fixation on Wilma, and the services of Mel Blanc were re-engaged after several episodes with a new and, it must be said, laughably wimpy voice for Twiki. When going through the second season episodes in order, I cheered to hear Blanc return as Twiki’s voice.

Season two isn’t short on familiar names either; Star Trek’s Mark “Sarek” Lenard puts in a headlining appearance in the double-length Journey To Oasis, and frequent-flyer original Trek director Vincent McEveety is behind the camera for several installments as well. But ultimately, it wasn’t enough to save Buck Rogers from cancellation.

The DVDs contain no bonus features, unless one counts the story synopses accompanying each episode. This set also features a bane of my digital video existence – easily-dirtied and easily-damaged double-sided discs – but at the same time, it’s two seasons, the entire run of the show, in a package that costs less than what some SF franchises charge for only one season on DVD. I guess I can’t knock that too much.

What is Buck Rogers’ place in the modern SF TV pantheon, especially when producers of more recent shows have obviously had old favorites like Buck and Battlestar Galactica in their sights when issuing edicts of “No cute kids and robots – EVER!”? It’s hard to say. The first season of Buck Rogers has such a huge quotient of cheesy fun that it’s hard not to crack a grin. I love serious science fiction, but there’s a place for light-hearted stories too, and I don’t mean Tripping The Rift. There’s a kinder, gentler side of SF that shines here, and I enjoyed reacquainting myself with it. There’s also something to be said for the show’s unabashed use of the last gasp of the great Universal Studios contract player system – if you can find me another SF show that had such a consistently star-studded lineup in the space of one year on the air, I’d like to hear about it.

However you slice it, Buck Rogers was a lot of fun. The DVD set could’ve used some extras (and reportedly the cast, including Gray and Gerard, were up for it – but Universal wouldn’t pay to secure their participation), so one point off there. But otherwise…in the words of a certain quad: “Beedy beedy beedy…hey Buck, you’re my kinda show.”… Read more

Categories
DVD TV Series Video

Blake’s 7: The Complete Series Three

5 min read

Order it in theLogBook.com StoreAs Terry Nation’s space opera entered its third season – originally intended to be its last – huge changes were underway in the series’ format. Perhaps the most significant of these was the fact that Blake, played by Gareth Thomas during the first two years, was no longer a regular part of the show, which naturally invited all sorts of questions about how the show could still be called Blake’s 7. But with the first two episodes written by Nation himself almost acting as a pilot for the show’s new direction, there was little doubt that this was the same show, continued, and not a spinoff. Blake’s crew was looking for him – whenever the business of surviving not only the totalitarian Federation, but the season opener’s alien armada, gave them that luxury. As the new leading man of the series, Paul Darrow as Avon came into his own, though the first few episodes handicap him with a kind of curious morality that Avon hadn’t exhibited before, and wouldn’t exhibit again later (due to BBC bosses’ concerns that you couldn’t have such a strongly amoral character as the hero). Jan Chappell and Michael Keating remained as Cally and Vila, respectively, with Jacqueline Pearce also continuing her role as the increasingly vampy villainess Servalan. Departing with Thomas were Sally “Jenna” Knyvette and Brian “Travis” Croucher.

Blake's 7: The Complete Series Three Blake's 7: The Complete Series Three

This necessitated filling out the Liberator’s crew roster anew, and young newcomers Dayna and Tarrant, played respectively by Josette Simon and Steven Pacey, joined up. One of this DVD set’s most unusual features, and an absolute treasure to see, is Pacey’s screen test, with Darrow feeding him lines from a confrontational scene in Power Play, the episode which really introduced Pacey’s character. Pacey plays the part more aggressively in his screen test, also lowering his voice (something the actor has since said was done to make him appear older than he was at the time for fear of not being believable in the role). In the end, Pacey played the character differently, so not only is the rarity of the footage part of its charm, but you get to see a very different performance than what was seen in the series.

Sadly, Pacey doesn’t appear in any of the commentaries, as I would’ve liked hearing more from him. Not that there’s really anything to complain about in this season: Jacqueline Pearce and Chris Boucher spend at least as much time getting caught up watching the story of Death-Watch as they do commenting on it, and Paul Darrow finally gets in on the DVD commentary action. He’s joined by Boucher and Jan Chappell for Rumours Of Death, and participates in what’s damn near a dream-team commentary on the season/series finale Terminal, along with Pearce, producer David Maloney, and Gareth “Blake” Thomas himself (who made a cameo return to his role in that last episode). Darrow is an absolute joy on these commentaries, delighting in pointing out how Shakespearean the show’s plotlines had become, and talking about his portrayal of Avon in general. Please, all of you, come back for the fourth season commentaries – and bring your castmates. For those of us who aren’t fortunate enough to be able to pop over to the U.K. to witness any of the live cast reunions whenever one of these DVD sets is released, this stuff is manna from heaven.

Blake's 7: The Complete Series Three Blake's 7: The Complete Series Three

Makeup artist Sheelagh Wells gets a featurette to herself here, recounting her work on the show’s stars and its alien creations as well (including the alien creation that led her to demand to have her name removed from the credits). She’s already covered some of this ground in her book Blake’s 7: The Inside Story, but as always there’s nothing to compare to hearing the person themselves speak. And while there are no deleted scenes per se here, there are outtakes, in the form of an edited-down version of film editor Sheila Tomlinson’s gag reel, which even includes the infamous “teddy bear” stunt pulled by Gareth Thomas during location filming for Terminal while trying to bust Darrow up in a particularly somber scene.

The “Introducing Dayna” and “Introducing Tarrant” featurettes are simply “best of” compilations of clips featuring those characters and explaining their backgrounds, but in the end it’s just a compressed version of what you’d get if you just watched the episodes yourself. And finally, there’s another Kevin Davies-edited trailer for the next (and final) season, set perfectly to the operatic strains of Mark Ayres’ score for The Innocent Sleep. Sadly, Davies’ full-length Blake's 7: The Complete Series Threedocumentary, vetoed since the first season box set by B7 Enterprises (the outfit Paul Darrow ended his association with which has still not gotten a Blake’s 7 revival of any kind beyond the drawing board), is still a no-show. Here’s hoping against hope that maybe B7E will come to its senses and finally let that show out of the bag in the upcoming season 4 set.

The third season has the bizarre distinction of containing my all-time favorite episode (the very off-format Sarcophagus, almost the first SF TV musical but not quite) and my least favorite (the utterly insipid Ultraworld), and even more strange than that is the fact that those two episodes ran back-to-back. But the sheer number of all-time classics here (Terminal, City At The Edge Of The World, Rumours Of Death, Aftermath, Death-Watch – funny, all of those episodes spring from the pen of either Terry Nation or script editor Chris Boucher) make this a must-get set. Trust me, Blake's 7: The Complete Series ThreeBlake’s 7 is a good reason to own a region-free DVD player.

And another good reason to own Blake’s 7’s third year on DVD: the limited edition which contained a perfect replica of the late 70s/early 80s Corgi die-cast Liberator toy. I already had one of the original toys, quite well-worn, but this thing is just beautiful in its little plastic Blake’s 7 bubble – I think I’ll keep it in there.

Blake's 7: The Complete Series Three Blake's 7: The Complete Series Three
Read more

Categories
DVD Star Trek TV Series Video

Star Trek: Voyager – Season One

8 min read

Order it in theLogBook.com StoreI was there at the dawning of the fourth age of Trek-kind. Working at a Fox affiliate at the time, which had recently undergone a bit of mitosis and spawned a second TV station which was earmarked from early on as a potential UPN station, I was more keenly aware of Star Trek: Voyager than I was of any Trek spinoff before it. I was aware of it not only as a fan, but in a more businesslike sense. I cringed at the hasty exit of Genevieve Bujold, and cringed again when the WB premiered a week ahead of UPN (though, again at the time, I predicted they’d never make it when their coolest offering was the series of Michigan J. Frog commercial bumpers and their lead program was a pale clone of Married…With Children).

Star Trek: Voyager - Season One Star Trek: Voyager - Season One

Then Voyager premiered, on January 15th, 1995. I watched the live satellite feed at work – mainly because our little independent sister station hadn’t made the deadline for UPN’s consideration before the premiere. The local ABC station carried Voyager instead, dropping it into Next Generation’s old 10:40pm Saturday night time slot (ironically, at the time of this writing, that’s where I work now). The new series promised so much, and the cast was rich with possibilities, and the effects raised the bar from what we had come to expect from Next Generation. Star Trek lived again! And then, by the end of the season, Voyager’s greatest enemy was…cheese.

This set chronicles that first season, in broadcast order, and boy does it bring back the memories. Actually, the first season wasn’t bad at all – for most of it, Voyager truly was a worthy successor to the Trek throne. Kate Mulgrew, as Captain Janeway, doesn’t get nearly enough credit for endowing the series with a massive amount of credibility. Poor as the scripts were from time to time, Mulgrew was magnificent, never giving the character of Janeway anything less than her all. Even later on, when Voyager became more and more derivative and shallow, Mulgrew’s performance alone was enough to merit at least one viewing of any given episode. Actually, it’s a bit disingenuous for me to heap all the praise on her: the cast of Voyager was excellent across the board. If there was a single weak link, it may have eventually been Robert Beltran as Chakotay, though the drought of stories focusing on and strengthening his character is more at fault than the actor is – Beltran simply had nothing to work with later on while other characters, even newcomers, were more fully developed. In this first season, Beltran gets his juiciest material, in these early episodes where there’s a more sharply defined division between Voyager’s original crew and the Maquis rebels.

Star Trek: Voyager - Season One Star Trek: Voyager - Season One

Many of my thoughts, and those of fellow theLogBook.com writer Rob Heyman, on those early episodes have been chronicled here already, so to save a bit of time I’ll refer you to those early, written-the-day-after-the-episode-aired reviews. One thing that occurs in hindsight is how rollicking and fast-paced the series premiere, Caretaker, is. It cruises along at a breakneck pace, establishing – for better or worse – that Voyager would be an action-adventure series, with the emphasis on action. Next Generation’s more introspective moments would be a thing of the past, as would DS9’s engrossing empire-building and serialization. Voyager’s early fortè would be what former Next Generation producer Herb Wright dubbed “weird shit,” and that weirdness was the specialty of future executive producer Brannon Braga. The first two Voyager hours out of the gate after the pilot were time paradoxes, and strange ones even by Star Trek standards. The first real standout episode was Phage, which introduced the underused and/or misused Vidiians, a race of plague-stricken aliens whose only means of survival was harvesting organs from others. And even their first outing, though arguably their strongest, spent a great deal of time on more “weird shit”, including a space chase through a gigantic hall of mirrors big enough for Voyager herself to get lost in. The Cloud is a bizarre mix of a jeopardy plot and several character vignettes, all of which are jockeying for “A”-story status. Eye Of The Needle is one of the show’s better “tech” mysteries, a good example of a ship-based bottle show that works.

Star Trek: Voyager - Season One Star Trek: Voyager - Season One

And then the first real bona fide stinker hits in the form of Ex Post Facto, a murder mystery that can’t decide if it wants to focus on Tuvok as the investigator or Tom Paris as the wrongfully-accused suspect. The next few episodes are better-than-average and set up some far-reaching story arcs, particularly where Seska, a Maquis crewmember who turns out to have been a treacherous Cardassian spy all along, is concerned. Where I really got a kick in the stomach was from the episode Cathexis, yet another paint-by-numbers crewmembers-possessed-by-aliens plotline, a device that had grown miserably stale from what seemed like once-every-third-week use on Next Generation. Following that, Faces at least scores points for being one of Voyager’s better attempts at horror, while Jetrel does an interesting war-criminal-meets-war-survivor tale and gives Ethan Phillips a chance to do some heavy drama that belies his appearance. With Learning Curve, there’s an interesting story about Tuvok trying to give some of the more rebellious Maquis crew a crash-course in proper Starfleet protocol, but it’s brought down by a B-plot in which Voyager – a ship that has survived being transported 70,000 light years, bombarded by Kazons, attacked by Vidiians, and brought to a halt by a warp core ejection – is sent to its knees by cheese. The predictable feel-good ending of the episode doesn’t help matters either.

Star Trek: Voyager - Season OneAs with previous Star Trek series DVDs, there are no commentaries, but there’s at least a healthy slate of bonuses taking up the set’s fifth disc. Featurettes examine the location shooting, special effects, and the creation of the series itself, and one nice featurette gives Kate Mulgrew a chance to say whatever she wants about the show and on her work since, particularly her one-woman biographical play about Katherine Hepburn, Tea At Five. There’s a brief feature about the evolution of Star Trek on the world wide web, which to me is interesting because I’d forgotten how much the original Paramount Voyager site looked like…well, an only slightly fancy fan site. But the show is really stolen by a featurette simply titled The First Captain: Bujold, offering us the first glimpses of Genevieve Bujold as Captain Nicole Janeway (changed from the original character name of Elizabeth to reflect Bujold’s middle name). Several scenes are shown in their entirety without any sort of commentary – comments are heard from Rick Berman in between scenes – and the difference between Bujold and Mulgrew is absolutely, jaw-droppingly striking. It’s not that Bujold plays Captain Janeway badly, or in some way that subverts the whole legacy of actors-as-starship-captains before her, but it’s so different – Bujold’s take is quiet and, in places, almost emotionless. It’s unfair to really deliver any kind of value judgement when we have nearly 200 hours of Mulgrew to hold up against several minutes of Bujold, but it’s interesting to finally see what might have been. Genevieve Bujold herself wasn’t interviewed for the featurette – not much of a surprise, what with the press reports of the time attributing to her a quote about not wanting to play “a comic book character” anymore – and Berman remains very complimentary of her, but admits that her style of working is more suited to filming a movie.

Sadly absent from the proceedings is the late-1994 Robert Picardo-hosted documentary Star Trek: Voyager – Inside The New Adventures, distributed by UPN to its newly-signed-up affiliate stations to air…well, really, whenever, however and as often as they wanted to. I remember running this hour-long (well, 40-odd minutes with commercial breaks) program endlessly in time slots where infomercials hadn’t been sold, and as sick as I grew of it at the time, I have to admit to being sad that it’s not featured here. No doubt, a lot of this box set’s extra feature material was originally shot for the special (though I’m sure there where hints even then of digital media that would demand value-added material), and yet there are quite a few interesting bits from that special that didn’t make it to DVD.

A mixed bag as far as the episodes themselves go, but the bonus features – especially the truly unusual sight of Genevieve Bujold occupying the captain’s seat – just about make up for it. Is it worth the price? Hard to say. Paramount is charging as much for this five-disc set as they previously charged for seven-disc sets of Next Generation and Deep Space Nine, which is just short of highway robbery in my book. It really depends on how much you liked this season of this particular series.… Read more

Categories
DVD TV Series Video

Babylon 5: The Complete First Season – Signs and Portents

5 min read

Order it in theLogBook.com StoreMan, have I been waiting for this.

The first season of Babylon 5 can only be described as uneven. Just look at disc 4, where the pivotal Signs And Portents shares space with the much-less-pivotal Grail and TKO. But even while the show was finding its legs, its potential was clear. And when it delivered on that potential, it was something very special.. The five-year-arc for television has been discussed over and over again, but to me that’s not the strength of Babylon 5. Series creator J. Michael Straczynski mentions it repeatedly in his episode commentaries…it’s a series that passionately argues that we all can make a difference in the world, that we all need to believe in ourselves and each other. It’s a show that has something to say, and is willing to take risks in order to say it. And thanks to this DVD set, I get to watch its beginnings over and over again, with a much better picture than the faded videotapes a certain webmaster sent to help me catch up on the show when I first became hooked.

Babylon 5: The Complete First Season Babylon 5: The Complete First Season

My favorite episode of the season, And The Sky Full Of Stars, is a perfect example of the show clicking. It takes Sinclair’s battles with his survivor’s guilt and missing memories and transforms them into gripping drama, drama that is played out more through words than action. Straczynski doesn’t completely hold back from the action, though – he would wait for season 4’s Intersections In Real Time for that – as we get to see the Battle of the Line for the first time thanks to some terrific CG animation work. (Christopher Franke’s Requiem For The Line is but one reason why I find the sequence here to be vastly superior to its expanded treatment in In The Beginning.) Michael O’Hare’s performance in the episode makes even a fan of Bruce Boxleitner’s Captain Sheridan such as myself wish that Sinclair hadn’t been moved off the chessboard quite so soon.

That move is one of the behind-the-scenes stories Straczynski relates in his episode commentaries for Signs And Portents and Chrysalis. Those fans who have gone through the bulk of Straczynski’s Usenet and GEnie postings over the years probably won’t find much new to chew on (although they will find some), but those who haven’t will likely feel more enlightened when they’re done. And even if the material’s not fresh, Straczynski’s delivery of it is. His combination of wit, pride, and self-deprecation are huge fun to listen to. Although when you are done, two facts will be burned into your mind – he really wanted to create a saga for American television even though no one said it would work, and Ivanova’s Russian pessimism reflects his own heritage.

Babylon 5: The Complete First Season Babylon 5: The Complete First Season

Other extras include two documentaries, The Making of Babylon 5 and Back to Babylon 5. The former is a 1994 piece hosted by Walter Koenig made to promote the first season, filled with cast/crew interviews and behind-the-scenes footage. The latter is a brand new featurette wholly comprised of interview clips with select cast and crew reflecting on the show and its beginnings. (Among the interviewees: Straczynski, fellow executive producer Douglas Netter, series stars Jerry Doyle, Richard Biggs and Stephen Furst, production designer John Iacovelli, makeup artist John Vulich, and producer John Copeland.) On its own, the new documentary would be rather thin, but it provides a very nice bookend to the old one, since you can see everyone express their hopes and plans for the series and then see them after they know how it all turns out. (Kind of like the virtues of rewatching these early episodes knowing where everyone’s going to wind up, in fact.)

There’s also an interactive guide to the Universe of Babylon 5, which has some brief nuggets of info on the station and characters, an introduction from Straczynski, and biographical info on Straczynski and Netter. My favorite little extra is the previews for each episode, which in a previous life served as the “Next week on Babylon 5…” promos. Watch some of these, and wonder if the people who watched them could have gotten any farther from the actual plotlines of the episodes in question.

Babylon 5: The Complete First Season Babylon 5: The Complete First Season

The episodes are presented in a widescreen format, which has caused some controversy and confusion within the fan community. The live action footage was shot on Super 35 film, which can then cropped into either full-frame or widescreen ratios. However, all the CG animation and any composite shots were composed exclusively on the full frame versions. So on the DVDs, shots that are completely live action will show more than the old full frame versions, although the new version might still lose some content from the old. CG shots or shots with composited elements are cropped from the original full frame, so these shots are always “missing” something from the top and bottom. Some, like myself, think the widescreen versions generally have an improved composition. Others prefer the original format. You’ll have to come to your own conclusions, but here’s a site that explains the process and shows side by side examples of the difference between full frame and widescreen B5.

Regardless of your stance on the aspect ratio, if you have any fondness at all for Babylon 5, you’ll enjoy having this set. As I said, I’ve been waiting for this for a long time, and I can say the wait was worth it.

Of course, now the wait for season 2 begins…… Read more

Categories
DVD Movies Star Trek TV Series Video

Star Trek: The Motion Picture – The Director’s Edition

7 min read

Order it in theLogBook.com StoreOften hailed as love-it-or-hate-it fare among Star Trek fans, Star Trek: The Motion Picture remains possibly my favorite movie of the entire franchise to date. Seriously. I’m not joking.

What do I like about ST:TMP? Maybe that it’s as brainy and as close to hard science fiction as the original Trek franchise ever got. Granted, that probably didn’t gain this movie the widest possible audience, but in 1979, Star Trek was thought of more fondly than it is by the public in 2002, and also in 1979, the most likely audience for a Star Trek flick was Trekkers themselves – so it was safe to throw a bit of real SF at them. Future movies made much more obvious attempts to appeal to a broad action-adventure audience.

Star Trek: The Motion Picture - The Director's Edition Star Trek: The Motion Picture - The Director's Edition

And contrary to all the complaints about an antiseptic, emotionless feel, I thought ST:TMP did a great job of taking the characters where we left off at the end of the original series and building on them, with some hints as to what they’d been doing in the interim, and some expansion on the characters, bringing them from the stereotypes that they occasionally were in the original TV series to more fully-rounded characters.

The double-disc DVD edition of ST:TMP revamps only a handful of special effects shots, but does a great deal more in the cutting room. Entire sequences with which fans are well-acquainted are dropped, the editing is generally tightened up, and the picture is digitally remastered overall, providing a very crisp visual. The effects replacements are very minor indeed, with only a few even standing out – the formation of the bridge leading from the Enterprise saucer to V’Ger’s central complex, an exterior shot of V’Ger (based on original 1978 production sketches) approaching Earth, and a shot of the Enterprise blasting the asteroid which throws it into a wormhole.

There’s just one problem with reworking and re-editing the visuals – the sound mix has to match. And this is one of my most glaring complaints with this otherwise nifty update to one of my favorite movies. In a small number of places, the legendary Jerry Goldsmith music score is butchered in the editing process, and there’s something else which pervades the entire film in this new version which I find even more intensely annoying: they seem to have lost the original sound effects source material and had to start from scratch. In some cases, sound effects hearkening back to those from the original series are used, which makes some sense, but in other cases completely different sounds are used, including one of the most annoying red alert sirens I’ve heard since the animated series. As many times as I’d seen ST:TMP, I found that this new sound mix was more than just a little bit distracting. Granted, those charged with remixed the soundtrack into Dolby 5.1 Surround probably had to start from scratch for their surround sound mix, but the techology exists to lift some of the effects from the original audio track of the movie – it’s not asking too much, really.

Star Trek: The Motion Picture - The Director's Edition Star Trek: The Motion Picture - The Director's Edition

I was stunned that some oddities of the original film weren’t fixed. In several scenes on the Enterprise bridge, you probably noticed instances where a blurry area seemed to smudge the background scenery between two characters, in some cases even seeming to warp the background set in a funhouse-mirror way. According to the audio commentary (of which more in a moment), this was an unavoidable side-effect of a special multi-focus lens called a diopter, which Robert Wise was forced to use to compensate for the sets’ low lighting. Now, all of the diopter shots are locked-off, steady shots, for that aforementioned blur would’ve been much more noticeable otherwise. Why not fix that blur? Granted, it might necessitate painting in set details in the background that may not match up, but frankly, I find that blur far more distracting then whether there should be two or three little round monitors on the panel behind Kirk and Decker. I suppose it might drive others crazy, but the diopter blur makes my teeth itch, to say nothing of my eyes.

The 2-disc set is rounded out by the most elaborate package of Trek extras Paramount has yet assembled, including no fewer than three special documentaries, an audio commentary from several key members of the behind-the-scenes crew and actor Stephen Collins, a full slate of TV and theatrical promo trailers, and an on-screen “text commentary” by Trek expert Michael Okuda. The documentaries are the real prize here, particularly the too-short-by-far piece on the aborted Star Trek Phase II television series which eventually mutated into the first Star Trek feature film. For the first time ever, the legendary screen test footage of the engineering sets, Persis Khambatta trying on one of the original series miniskirt uniforms, and David Gautreaux’s screen test for the part of new Vulcan science officer Xon are seen. Numerous new interviews help tell the story, though truth be told, one would be better off having read Judith & Garfield Reeves-Stevens’ book on the series that wasn’t before seeing this. Still, it’s a real treat finally getting to see that stuff, and it makes one wonder if we might wind up seeing the existing footage of Genevieve Bujold as Star Trek: Voyager’s Captain Janeway someday in a Voyager DVD box set.

The other two documentaries cover the making of the movie in general, with some annoying self-back-patting from Shatner and Nimoy, and a look at the restoration and re-working of the film. Some of the stuff in the documentaries makes me cringe with the cloying, pro-Paramount Studios spin that has been put on them – it’s common knowledge that ST:TMP was, behind the scenes, an excessively troubled movie – and if Paramount itself thought so highly of it, why did future movies only put Gene Roddenberry on the payroll as a consultant whose advice didn’t have to be heeded? I would’ve been happier with some more frank discussion in these interview segments.

The TV ads and teaser trailers are also highlights of the bonus features, with their very 70s and very cheesy ad copy and stand-in effects. Hindsight being 20/20, and being a promo writer myself, I can think of about a dozen ways this movie could have been teased better. But the tight filming schedule and availability of any footage, either special effects shots or from the set, probably made it challenge to come up with any kind of a pitch that would sell this movie. And hey, they’re better than the original theatrical trailers for Star Wars by far.

A little bit more mystifying is a sales-pitch-esque preview/promo for Enterprise, the latest ship off the old Star Trek block. Why this was included, I’m not sure, when there were other things much more closely related to ST:TMP that aren’t on here, including the original 1978 press conference announcing the movie’s production – footage of this event, which happened the same day as NASA rolling out the space shuttle test orbiter Enterprise, does still exist.

Mike Okuda’s text commentary is informative, sure to please triviaholics, and most of all funny. When Kirk notes for the umpteenth time that the Enterprise is the only Starfleet ship standing between Earth and V’Ger, Okuda’s subtitle pops up: “This seems to happen a lot.”

Though my qualms with some aspects of the presentation – most notably the sound effects and the hack-‘n’-slash music editing – keep me from, in all good conscience, giving this title a four-star rating, I do still recommend Star Trek: The Motion Picture – The Director’s Edition to Trek fans out there. However it sounds, the movie has never looked better.… Read more